Wednesday, April 9, 2008

Youth Crime Laws Need to Change

This morning, there is a Canadian Press news story about Winnipeg police arresting a 10-year-old boy who has set nearly three dozen fires in the city. Furthermore, the police have no option to pursue criminal charges against this young criminal because his is less than 12 years old.

This is completely unacceptable and outrageous. The youth exemption was put in place in the Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA) to prevent children from being charged when they cannot differentiate between right and wrong in their actions. Any child who sets more than 30 fires using Molotov cocktails is no doe-eyed innocent deserving of protection. This is deliberate, premeditated, and habitual criminal activity and it should be treated as such.

While I do concede that some youth crime is the result of youthful exuberance or getting accidentally and temporarily caught up with the wrong group of friends, a great deal of results from repeat and violent young offenders. Despite their age, these criminals are no different than an adult committing the same crime.

I firmly believe that it is time for the government to introduce substantive amendments to the YCJA in order to properly address youth crime in Canada. We need our laws to recognize and reflect the current realities of young offenders in Canada.

What do you think on this issue? Agree? Disagree? Suggestions?

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

They may not be able to charge due to his age but I bet you dollars to donuts that this Kid will be in a Foster home/ Group home faster then you can blink. It's a well known fact that Kids that set fires are usually victims of serious abuse. Parents that have no control can lose them if it is deemed injurious to the Child's natural development. Sucks, but at least the resources will be there to turn this kid around, if it can still be done. Every move and utterance will be monitored and scrutinized. Classic case of the state needs to step in some how and quick.

Anonymous said...

Until parents can be charged, the problems won't go away. Winnipeg has a huge gang problem and it's a small number of kids committing most of the crimes. A great number of these kids are aboriginal and until somebody addresses this honestly, the problem won't go away. The aboriginal community needs to get together to try to come to grips with why this is so.